Chicago · Fees and Case Costs

Contingency Fees and Case Costs in an Illinois Truck Accident Case: What Is Owed Upfront and What Happens if the Case Is Lost

Illinois requires contingency fee agreements to be in writing and to state how case costs are handled. This guide explains the difference between attorney fees and case costs, and what you may owe if a truck case is lost.

Available 24/7 · No fee unless we win · Licensed in Illinois

Chicago expressway traffic

Do I pay anything upfront to hire a truck accident lawyer in Illinois?

Usually not. Under a contingency agreement, the fee is a percentage of any recovery, and the firm typically advances case costs — Illinois Rule 1.5(c) requires the agreement to be in writing and signed.

Overview

Few people plan for the moment they need a lawyer, and fewer still plan for it while recovering from a collision with an 80,000-pound commercial truck. In the weeks after a crash, the questions tend to arrive all at once — medical bills, missed paychecks, a damaged vehicle, and an insurance adjuster who calls more often than you would like.

That said, one question often holds people back from getting help at all: what will a lawyer cost, and what happens if the case is lost? We understand that worry, and the answer should be on paper before you sign anything.

This guide explains how contingency fee agreements work in Illinois, how case costs differ from attorney fees, and who pays for expert witnesses if the case does not succeed. Keep in mind that every firm writes its own agreement, so the details below are the questions to ask rather than promises about any particular contract.

How A Contingency Fee Agreement Works In Illinois

Most plaintiff truck accident cases in Illinois are handled on a contingency basis. Under that arrangement, the lawyer's fee is a percentage of whatever is recovered through settlement or verdict, and if nothing is recovered, no attorney fee is owed.

Illinois regulates these agreements through Rule 1.5(c) of the Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct. The rule requires a contingent fee agreement to be in writing and signed by the client, and it requires the agreement to spell out several specific terms.

Under Rule 1.5(c), a written contingency agreement must state, among other things:

  • The method of calculating the fee. This includes the percentage or percentages that apply in the event of settlement, trial, or appeal.
  • The litigation and other expenses to be deducted. The agreement must identify the categories of costs that will come out of any recovery.
  • Whether expenses come out before or after the fee. This single term can change the amount you take home, as the example later in this guide shows.
  • Any expenses you owe regardless of outcome. The lawyer must clearly notify you of any expense for which you will be liable whether or not you are the prevailing party.

At the end of the case, the same rule requires the lawyer to give you a written statement showing the outcome, the amount sent to you, and how that amount was calculated. In other words, the agreement at the start and the closing statement at the end are both required documents, not courtesies.

Percentages And Stages

Illinois does not set a statutory percentage schedule for truck accident claims. By comparison, the legislature has set a sliding fee schedule for medical malpractice cases under 735 ILCS 5/2-1114, but that statute applies to medical malpractice, not to motor carrier crashes.

As a result, the percentage in a truck case is a matter of agreement, subject to the general requirement in Rule 1.5(a) that a fee be reasonable. Many agreements use a tiered structure, with one percentage if the case settles before suit and a higher percentage if it proceeds through trial or appeal.

The reasoning behind tiers is practical. A case that goes to trial requires far more attorney time, more depositions, and more expert work than one that settles after a demand letter.

What If More Than One Firm Is Involved?

Some truck cases are referred from one lawyer to another or handled jointly by two firms. Rule 1.5(e) permits lawyers in different firms to divide a fee only if the division is proportionate to the work each performs or each lawyer assumes joint financial responsibility, the client agrees in writing, and the total fee is reasonable.

Remember that a referral arrangement should not raise your total percentage. If two firms are involved, the agreement should say so, and you should know which lawyer is actually handling your case day to day.

Attorney Fees And Case Costs Are Two Different Things

The attorney fee pays for the lawyer's time, judgment, and skill. Case costs, by contrast, are the out-of-pocket expenses needed to investigate and prove the claim, and they are tracked separately.

This distinction matters more in truck litigation than in an ordinary car accident case. A commercial carrier case often turns on electronic and regulatory evidence that requires technical experts to collect, preserve, and interpret.

Common case costs in an Illinois truck accident claim include but are not limited to:

  • Court filing and service fees. These are the clerk's fees to open the case and the cost of formally serving each defendant.
  • Electronic data recovery. Downloading and analyzing engine control module and electronic logging device data, which we cover in our guide to ELD data preservation in Chicago truck cases.
  • Accident reconstruction. A reconstructionist may inspect the scene, the tractor-trailer, and your vehicle to establish speed, braking, and sightlines.
  • Trucking safety experts. These experts compare the carrier's practices against the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, including hours-of-service rules in 49 CFR Part 395 and driver qualification rules in 49 CFR Part 391.
  • Medical and economic experts. Life care planners, physicians, vocational experts, and economists help quantify future care, lost earning capacity, and other long-term losses.
  • Depositions and transcripts. Court reporter fees, transcript costs, and videographer fees add up quickly when multiple drivers, dispatchers, and safety managers are deposed.
  • Records and storage. Medical records, police reports, and, in some cases, the cost of storing a damaged vehicle so it remains available for inspection.

The number of defendants also drives costs. A crash that involves a driver, a motor carrier, a broker, a trailer owner, and a maintenance vendor can mean separate discovery against each one, as explained in our overview of who can be liable after a truck crash.

Who Pays These Costs As The Case Moves Forward?

Illinois Rule 1.8(e) allows a lawyer to advance court costs and expenses of litigation, and repayment of those advances may be made contingent on the outcome of the matter. In practice, this means many plaintiff firms pay case costs as they arise and seek reimbursement only from a recovery.

As a result, most injured people do not write checks for experts or filing fees while the case is pending. However, the agreement controls, so confirm in writing that the firm advances costs and does not expect periodic payments from you.

Be aware that some firms charge interest on advanced costs or finance them through an outside lender. If that is the arrangement, the agreement should disclose the rate and how it is calculated.

Who Pays For Experts And Costs If The Case Is Lost

This is the question that worries people most, and it has two separate parts. The first part concerns your own lawyer's fees and costs, and the second concerns the other side's costs.

Your Own Lawyer's Fees And Costs

Under a contingency agreement, if there is no recovery, there is no attorney fee. That part is built into the definition of a contingent fee.

Case costs are where agreements differ. Because Rule 1.5(c) requires the lawyer to clearly notify you of any expenses you owe whether or not you prevail, the answer should appear in plain language in your contract.

Agreements generally fall into one of two approaches:

  • The firm absorbs costs on a loss. The firm advanced the costs, and if there is no recovery, it does not seek repayment from you.
  • The client remains responsible for costs. The agreement states that you must repay advanced costs even if the case is lost, which can be a significant sum in an expert-heavy truck case.

Our firm handles truck accident cases on a contingency basis, and you will not pay lawyer's fees unless we recover compensation for you. Whatever firm you choose, ask the question directly and make sure the written answer matches the verbal one.

The Other Side's Costs

Illinois allows a prevailing defendant to recover certain court costs under 735 ILCS 5/5-108. Note that "costs" in this statutory sense are generally limited to taxable court costs, such as filing and service fees, rather than the defense's attorney fees or expert witness fees.

Under the general American rule followed in Illinois, each side ordinarily pays its own attorney fees unless a statute or contract says otherwise. Accordingly, losing a truck case does not usually mean paying the trucking company's lawyers, although the exact exposure in a given case is a question for your attorney.

How The Settlement Money Is Divided At The End

When a truck case resolves, the money is typically paid into the law firm's client trust account rather than directly to the client. From there, the firm pays the fee, reimburses costs, resolves liens, and sends the remaining balance to you along with the written closing statement Rule 1.5(c) requires.

Before-Cost Versus After-Cost Calculation

The order of deductions is the term people most often overlook. To illustrate, consider a hypothetical settlement of $300,000 with $30,000 in case costs and a one-third contingency fee — these figures are for arithmetic only and do not reflect any real case or expected value.

Here is how the two methods compare:

  • Fee calculated on the gross recovery. The fee is one-third of $300,000, or $100,000, and then $30,000 in costs is deducted, leaving $170,000 before liens.
  • Costs deducted first, then the fee. The $30,000 in costs comes off first, leaving $270,000, and one-third of that is $90,000, leaving $180,000 before liens.

In this example, the difference is $10,000 to the client on the same settlement. Both methods are permitted in Illinois, which is exactly why the rule requires the agreement to say which one applies.

Medical Liens And Reimbursement Claims

After the fee and costs, liens are often the next largest deduction. Hospitals, treating physicians, health insurers, and government programs such as Medicare or Medicaid may each assert a right to be repaid from your recovery.

The Illinois Health Care Services Lien Act, 770 ILCS 23, caps the combined liens that health care providers can assert against a personal injury recovery. Health plans and federal programs follow their own rules, and a lawyer's work negotiating reductions can meaningfully change your net recovery.

For a broader look at what drives the size of a recovery and how long it takes to receive it, see our guides on how Illinois truck settlement value is determined and the Chicago truck accident settlement timeline.

Questions To Ask Before You Sign A Fee Agreement

A fee agreement is a contract, and you are entitled to read it slowly, take it home, and ask questions before you sign. A reputable firm will welcome those questions rather than rush you.

Here is a list of questions worth asking any truck accident lawyer you are considering:

  • What is the percentage at each stage? Ask whether the rate changes if suit is filed, if the case goes to trial, or if there is an appeal.
  • Are costs deducted before or after the fee? Ask the firm to show you the math on a sample number so the difference is concrete.
  • Who pays costs if the case is lost? Get the answer in the written agreement, not only in conversation.
  • Is interest charged on advanced costs? If so, ask for the rate and whether an outside lender is involved.
  • Which expenses are you likely to need? In a truck case, ask whether the firm expects to retain reconstruction, trucking safety, and medical experts, and how those decisions will be made.
  • Who will handle my case? Ask whether the case will be referred or co-counseled, and how any fee division works under Rule 1.5(e).
  • How will I be kept informed about costs? Some firms provide periodic cost updates, which can help you understand the case's direction.
  • What happens if I change lawyers? You may discharge a lawyer at any time, and Illinois courts generally limit a discharged lawyer to the reasonable value of the work performed, usually paid from the eventual recovery.

Timing matters as well. Evidence in a truck case — electronic logs, dashcam footage, and driver qualification files — can be lost if no one moves to preserve it, which is why we encourage people to review the steps in our guide to the first 72 hours after a semi crash even before choosing a lawyer.

In addition, Illinois generally allows two years to file a personal injury lawsuit under 735 ILCS 5/13-202. Keep in mind that exceptions and different deadlines can apply, so the clock is one more reason not to let fee questions delay a consultation.

Talk With Our Chicago Truck Accident Lawyers

A serious truck crash can change your health, your income, and your family's plans in a single moment. We understand that the last thing you need is uncertainty about what hiring a lawyer will cost.

Our Chicago truck accident lawyers explain the fee agreement line by line before you sign, including the percentage, how costs are handled, and what happens if there is no recovery. We advance the costs of investigating and proving your case, and we work with reconstruction, trucking safety, and medical experts to build it.

Have you or a loved one been injured in a crash involving a commercial truck in Chicago or elsewhere in Illinois? We welcome the opportunity to speak with you about your situation and help you determine the next steps.

Please contact Chicago Truck Accident Lawyers to schedule a free and confidential consultation. Free consultation — no fee unless we recover.

This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney in your jurisdiction about your specific situation.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Reading
Free Consultation

Get your free case evaluation today

Were you or a loved one injured in a crash involving a commercial truck in the Chicago area? Get a free, confidential case evaluation.

Chicago skyline at sunset over Lake Michigan with the John Hancock Center and Willis Tower
Location

Find Us

Chicago Truck Accident Lawyers
1132 S Wabash Ave, Suite 303
Chicago, IL 60605-2305

Call 24/7312.728.2989

Get Directions